Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts

Monday, March 15, 2010

On Politics and Friendships

The Israeli, and partly also the American, media are discussing lately the issue of the Obama administration's reaction to the Israeli government's decision to build 1600 housing units in East Jerusalem. Thomas Friedman of the New York Times had some spare thoughts to share, which the Wall Street Journal repudiated. In light of this discussion, I will share my 2 cents. I know I am not exactly a publicist or a renowned blogger, but still there is one thing that bothers me about the way the administration is pressing the Israeli government. But before that, a word of warning: I am what Israelis might call "left-wing"; I fully support the right of the Palestinians to have a state alongside Israel, I support the so called "Two States Solution", I supported the withdrawal of Israeli settlers from the Gaza Strip and I object to building in the Israeli settlements in the West Bank. Now that this is out of our way, let's take a deep breath and see how the Obama administration, with senior Jewish officials (Rahm Emanuel and David Axelrod), is acting in their worst interests, instead of the required, assuming that the administration indeed wants to get the peace process working.

It is often said that special relations between Israel and the USA are founded on the premises of joint values, democracy being one of such main values. Israel is, in fact, the only openly democratic republic in the Middle East. It is so democratic, in fact, that in the last fifteen (15) years since 1996 there were six (6) elections. This democratic instability is caused by many factors, which are not the scope of this post. However, the main things to mention are that Israel is a democracy, an unpredicted one at that, and that the fragmented political map in Israel makes it impossible for a government to complete its four years' term. One may ask, what does it have to do with the Obama administration? Well, in short, everything. Since the Obama administration wants democracy to proliferate in the world, it should also show some respect to its, occasionally, undesired side effects, namely that an undesired political side gets into power. Undoubtedly, having a right-wing Israeli government, in which Avigdor Lieberman is Foreign Minister, is hardly a desired partner in American eyes. Nonetheless, it is still the elected government. The last campaign was unique in the way that one side, the Israeli right in this case, decidedly won the elections. And, being the right wing that they are, the ticket that got them there was expanding the settlement in Judea and Samaria, which, according to their voters, is, has been, and shall always be, part of the Jewish Holy Land. I might argue with that, but as the side that lost the elections, I respect their views and hope for the best in the next elections.

In my view, this is where the Obama officials show their infuriating combination of hypocrisy and inexperience. Hypocrisy because they do not accept the vote of the Israeli people, and force Prime Minister Netanyahu to accept their terms, which are contradictory to the ticket he was elected with. Not only that, by doing so the administration is deliberately trying to undermine Prime Minister Netanyahu's government by alienating his coalition partners. The inexperience part comes from the lack of understanding in Israeli politics. If they knew better, the administration would know that what they are doing will cause the Israeli public, including left wing people like myself, to rally in support of their government. I may not like the government's decisions, but I am definitely against foreign countries' meddling in our decision making.

And, yes, it is, in lack of better term, meddling with Israeli internal affairs. This is hardly the first time American administration did it to Israel, or to other countries. However, this time the administration has crossed the line between mild meddling and acting forcibly to destabilize the elected Israeli government. To make it clearer to American eyes, this would be parallel to a foreign superpower (China perhaps) forcing the administration to stop its healthcare reform, claiming it to be too expensive (China is after all America's largest creditor) by destabilizing Obama's administration using international and internal pressure on decision makers. I am certain that if this was the case, the Obama administration would not accept it silently, and certainly would not apologize for not doing so, as Netanyahu did. If anything, the administration reaction would be to denounce this act of meddling in American internal affairs and the American people would not accept it either. So, it is of great wonder to me that the administration expects the Israeli government and people to accept this breach of Israeli sovereignty.

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Another thought: liberty and counter-terrorism

It has been argued in the past that in order to defeat terrorism a nation has to gather information about the intents of its enemies, both domestic and foreign. In the wake of the atrocious 9-11 attacks on the United States, the horrific attacks in Madrid on March-11 2004, and the terrorist attacks on London's tube on July 7, 2005, it seems that governments are bent towards the use of more invasive measures to generate information. However, while their intent is undeniably good, it seems that they (and us) have forgotten to stop and think: isn't it just what the terrorists want? To undermine and perhaps even shutter the foundations of Western Civilizations, namely: human rights and liberties.
Here in the United States there is a growing debate regarding the measures used to investigate terrorists and those suspected of being terrorists. President Obama has repeatedly said in his campaign that he will either accuse or release the prisoners held at Guantanamo Bay, but will not keep them in custody without end. The issue is not that simple, though. For example what do you do with someone who you know is a terrorist, but you cannot disclose your sources. Should you risk the life of your source, hence risk the chance of getting new information about terrorist organizations? Or is it better to let this obvious danger be loose.
In the United Kingdom this debate has intensified over the endless measures taken by the British government to collect data over the subjects of the union. One must remember that in the UK, as well as in the USA, there are no "itentity cards". This comes from a history of long tradition, where every citizen (or subject) of the state shall not limit his or her liberties due to the use of identity cards. However, the UK is now approaching a state that monitors every subject including all his or her phone calls, cellular location, emails and messages. For the average Briton this is as radical a move as it would be for an Islamist terrorist to repent his deeds and become Catholic Christian. Unsurprisingly, this was too much not just for the ordinary person on the street, but also for one of the most prestigious counter-terrorism agents in the world, Dame Stella Rimington, the former Director General of the British MI5. The Dame has said in an interview for a Spanish journal that the measures taken and proposed by the government are too much, or in her words: "It would be better that the Government recognised that there are risks, rather than frightening people in order to be able to pass laws which restrict civil liberties, precisely one of the objects of terrorism: that we live in fear and under a police state". Naturally, the Home Office in Great Britain has come up with a response saying that she is "Wrong to suggest that had all the things we planned been passed we'd have been a police state, and wrong to suggest we have somehow stumbled towards a police state."
Again, there is no solution to the problem I state. However, one must always check and see whether the measures taken on behalf of society in order to counter terrorism are not somehow undermining the most important foundations of that same society. I think that some signs of fear over this dangerous trend towards a modern police-state already start to show.

Saturday, February 14, 2009

Weekly thought: is democracy the right policy?

I didn't update about our lives in the previous week, because I was simply too busy to do that. For the same reason, you can also assume that our lives are as boring as can be, and I will not bore you with the minutiae that surround them. The only interesting thing that happened this week were the recurrent Tornado sirens that were sounded all around our area. It appears that whenever there is a thunderstorm in the area these sirens go off, and they sound exactly like air raid sirens. Of course, the alarms were false, and as I understand they usually are. My students and I have concluded that they are another form of the story about the boy who cried "wolf". Instead of a weekly summary you're all invited to share my "weekly thought".

Thus, the only interesting thing about the previous two weeks were the Israeli elections. My views on the success of Israeli democracy have long been known, even before the outcome of this elections, which is again: total stagnation to the point that no one even knows who won. In general, I think that a democracy that generates 5 elections in 10 years (1999, 2001, 2003, 2006, and 2009) is spinning out of control. Moreover, the rate at which elections are held is increasing, as in the previous two decade only 5 were held (1981, 1984, 1988, 1992, and 1996). Respectively, the size of the biggest party in the elections is gradually shrinking, from only once below 40 seats (34 in 1996, 44 in 1992, 40 in 1988, 44 in 1984, and 48 in 1981) to only once above 30 seats (28 in 2009, 29 in 2006, 38 in 2003, 2001 elections were for the prime-minister office alone, and 26 in 1999), leaving the Knesset to be ever more divided between factions. Furthermore, the winning side, namely the side that formed the government, has changed in all but one of the last 5 elections (right in 1996, left in 1999, right in 2001 (only PM), right in 2003, center-left in 2006, and right again in 2009) whereas the government was formed by the same side between 1977 and 1999 (with the exception of national unity government led jointly by Likud and Maarach in 1984). In conclusion, the political system in Israel is all but stable, which makes it impossible to generate any kind of movement in any direction, and I don't just relate to Peace vs. War. Think, for example, about the number of national projects done in the first 2-3 decades of the country, and how many national projects have been started and finished since. It's easy: none were started in the last decade or two. I think that the last national project (although controversial one) was the Lavie. In conclusion, I think that the Israeli democratic system has failed, caused us nothing but painful and pricey stagnation, cost us much factionalism and self-hatred, and should be changed. The question is "change to what?" or "do you have another idea?".

Well, I don't. I think that democracy cannot work in any case, but I can neither prove it nor suggest a better way. I can only offer the words of one of my favorite authors, Robert A. Heinlein, who wrote in the book "Glory Road" the following paragraphs. Before them I'll just explain the circumstances: the main character joins an adventure in which he helps the "Empress of the 20 known universes" together with another character, Rufo, who is a comparative-culturolgist: he studies different cultures in the variety of universes. In one of their talks the hero repeats the words of another comparative-culturoligst (Nebbi) who think that the American democracy (which works a bit better than our own) is a "noble experiment", which is bound to fail. This is a quote from Rufo's reply:
"...Nebbi was right. Except that he sees only the surface. Democracy can't work. Mathematicians, peasants, and animals, that's all there is - so Democracy, a theory based on the assumption that mathematicians and peasants are equal, can never work. Wisdom is not additive; its maximum is that of the wisest man in a given group.

But a democratic form of government is okay, as long as it doesn't work. Any social organization does well enough if it isn't rigid. The framework doesn't matter as long as there is enough looseness to permit that one man in a multitude to display his genius. Most so-called social scientists seem to think that organization is everything. It is almost nothing - except when it is a straitjacket. It is the incidence of heroes that counts, not the pattern of zeros."
I would add that a similar notion of "looseness in government" should be used when thinking about the perfect organizational structure of a company. I guess I would not be alone in that thinking.

Sunday, November 2, 2008

Weekly summary #7: photos

First, I'll start with two administration notices:
  1. Some of you have repeatedly asked for photos. Here are some. Since the only drives we have are from the home to the university and back, and since our house is still a mess, the photos are only of the university. Maybe I'll add more later.
  2. I decided that the Verizon phone is so unusable that I left Verizon for T-mobile and now I use my Sony-Ericsson from home. On the other hand, I decided that it's not a good idea to put my phone on the net, so if you need it, just ask for my new phone. In any case, don't use the Verizon phone number.
  3. As always, you're encouraged to follow the links in this update.
The reason this update is late is the Obama rally we attended yesterday at the University of Cincinnati (video). We're not into politics that much, and in the previous post I mentioned that there's not enough interest in the coming elections, especially comparing to their importance to America and to the world. Apparently one the candidates has decided to spark things up and yesterday Senator Obama made an appearance in Nyppert Stadium at the University of Cincinnati. We decided to go, as this is probably the closest we'll ever get to the president of the United States, according to the polls. On the other hand, Shimon Peres has been elected several times in the polls so nothing is decided yet. Or, in other way, you can see this Simpsons clip to understand why McCain will be elected at the end, and pay special attention to the sentence in which Homer says: "... this does not happen in America...".

Before talking about the rally itself, I just want to give you another example on how this country and the people in this city are ready for a totalitarian regime. The doors of the stadium opened at 6, and we left my office at the university at 5 so that we'll have a good chance of getting in. Already there was a huge line. Everyone was standing in an organized fashion and we simply walked to the end of the line and joined it. People were standing on the road at that time, and then came a police officer and politely said: "folks, I need you to be on the pavement". In less than 5 seconds a group of more than 20 people moved to stand on the pavement, with no questions or arguments. Total adherence to the law-enforcement representative.

Anyway, I have some observations regarding Barack Obama as a candidate and possibly the next president of the United States (I guess you knew I would make some comments about him, right?).
Firstly, this is something we saw yesterday, and I don't know if it is not the same in the case of McCain, but the candidacy of Obama has made him a merchandise. We saw people selling everything with his face and name on: T-shirts, bumper stickers, car magnets, and even play cards (that had Bush and McCain as the jokers). Anything you want for a price that ranges from $1 to $25. He has become a rock star rather than a candidate. Again, this might be the case for John McCain as well (I know that Sarah Palin has become an icon as well, as I mentioned in the previous update). Just notice this link: www.barackobama.com in the picture I took yesterday.
Secondly, if the way Obama manages his time can give us any clue on the way he will run the next administration, then he will not do a good job. Yesterday we waited for him for 40 minutes before he appeared on stage, and that's after the other small-time politicians finished their speeches. The crowd around us, comprised mainly by supporters and fans of the Democratic party (unlike us, who were just there for the experience), was getting frustrated with his delay. Some said: "hey, we need to be at work tomorrow, those of us who still have work".
Thirdly, I genuinely think that there is no good candidate in the coming elections. Both Obama and McCain are ill-suited for this job. Obama is too young and inexperienced, although very charismatic judging by the female crowd around me yesterday even sexy, to comprehend and manage the current turmoil in the financial markets and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. McCain on the other hand is too old, and too attached to his Republican party, and to the legacy of the Bush administration. If there is something evident in the current situation, it is that this administration is probably the worst ever in the history of the United States. I think that what people seek is change, and Obama is change for them (his slogans are: "change" and "hope"), but in my view: to say "change" is not enough. In the terms of a systems engineer, you need to define the requirements in an unambiguous manner, and just saying "change" is not enough. You need a plan, preferably a feasible one, and I can't say I've heard one coming from the Obama campaign managers. For example, I think that his plans will leave a HUGE hole in the American budget, which will only drive this economy to a worse situation than it already is.
Last observation I have of Obama is that he started to feel too confident in his success. Yesterday, I heard him use the term "regime" for the current Bush government. I don't know how many of you are aware of the different terms the English language has for a government. Usually, the neutral term is "government", while a positive way to say it is "administration" (that's usually how Americans call their own government), and "regime" is the negative wording for such. Usually the word regime refers to the Irani government, or Saddam Hussein's government. When used in the context of the Bush government it has significant consequences on the way Barack Obama thinks.

Can an African American become the president of the United States with all the prejudices and bigotry here? A few months ago I was doubted that very much; now, in light of the economic crisis, I think that people are so aching for change that some of them are willing to overlook questions of race and color. According to the polls here, he will be elected. If he doesn't it will be the surprise of the century, but it will also show that underneath the surface there is still a dark current of hatred between the whites and blacks in America.

Moving on to other issues, we have started to think about our upcoming home visit. One thing that came up pretty quickly, not surprising given our bent towards good food and coffee, and the lack of such here, is our need for such. I don't know if we can afford too many of those, but we certainly would like to go to some of our favorite places in Tel Aviv, and until now the food wish-list includes:
  • Joya
  • Tamara
  • Vanillia
  • Arcaffe
  • A cafe near my home
  • A good Humus/lafa place (with emphasis on good!) for me
  • D wants to add Barbari or Yevulim
So, if something here sounds good to you as well, we will be happy to schedule a lunch or a dinner there. Also, if something good has opened since we left, that's fine by us.

Quick updates from the previous week:
  1. I finally got my first paycheck. Hurray! Only a month and a half without a salary.
  2. Still no updates on our other administrative issues with the university (i.e. domestic partnership).
  3. We went to a Halloween party organized by the graduate students at the College of Business. I think that it was the first time that I saw American women allow themselves to dress in "revealing" clothing. I think that more revealing clothing is considered "slutty" here (at least in Cincinnati). We were supposed to wear costumes, so D and I bought hats. She got a large hat and I got a fedora hat. I tried for the "great depression era unemployed". Unfortunately, they didn't have the fedora in red. Which brings me to the last update:
  4. Windows on my old laptop has finally crashed. I had to install the entire system with the KDE version of Ubuntu (version 8.10). That's the first time in my life that I use a computer with no Microsoft operating system installed on it. So far, apart from a few glitches, it behaves itself. We intend it to serve as our media center at home, and it takes some tweaking before you can do that in Linux (basically because of the proprietary media formats used everywhere). Ynet is still a mess with all the non-standard video streams they use, but nothing that a good Greasemonkey script and a good media player can't handle.
For those of you who got this far: mood-o-meter - high for me, low for D. Did you notice that we are at 180 degrees phase from each other?

Sunday, October 26, 2008

Weekly Summary 6: Politics and Bureaucracy

First of all I would like to thank all the people that sent encouraging words after the previous post. Your words are important and appreciated and I thank you for that. This week's post will deal with something most of us don't like at all: bureaucracy and politics. As I mentioned in some of the previous posts, we have encountered a frighteningly amount of red tape in our first weeks, starting with the problems of getting my university ID, entering me to the system and so on. Unfortunately, this has not ended yet. For example, I still haven't received the package with all my social rights and health care. The official "excuse" is that they sent it to another address, which is the hotel in which we had resided in the first two weeks. I doubt that very much, and my guess is that someone simply misplaced the package. My suspicions increased after my visit to the University's Human Resources, where a nice yet a total moron person told me that he will look for the package and let me know. He hasn't done that although almost a week has passed. This has become a major concern for me because now I'm starting to be sick, and I would like to go to a doctor if this condition persists.

Worse still, the same useless HR guy told me that we would not be able to apply for domestic partnership until a period of 6 months has passed since the beginning of D's relationship with me. And for them 6 months are counted from the date of the first document we have, which in our case is our lease on the apartment, dated from September. First of all, this domestic partnership is the only reason I am teaching here, instead of being a regular student. Don't think that I am the only one with incentive to do it; the department is very short in staff. In fact, they have two positions open, after two lecturers left in the previous year. They need me to teach no less than I need their money to support D's studies. If I don't get this domestic partnership approved, and we have to pay for D's tuition, which is circa $20000, I consider it to be a major breach of our contract. I intended to go down and tell the department head that if it is not sorted out, she can forget about me teaching and that we will go back home. D has managed to cool me off, and we intend to try and get this partnership approved using an old affidavit we made to the municipality of Tel Aviv (another bureaucratic superpower). Kelly promised to help as well, and seemed stressed by this new difficulty. In any case, if we don't get it, I guess I will have to have some serious and not so pleasant talk with the department head.

Now to politics. As you know, the presidential elections will be held on the next Tuesday. These are historic elections, and when they are over the United States will have either a first African American president, or a first female vice president. You might have suspected that this situation will raise a special interest in the elections, especially during a major economic crisis. As far as I can see, the students in the university are not so interested about it. Here they can vote ahead of the elections day, even today, and still I haven't seen any strong movement in the voting area. It is assumed that most younger people will vote for Obama, and if this is the case, don't be surprised if Mc'Cain wins the elections. In addition, elections day is not a vacation here; people are supposed to work in that day and then go to vote for their nominee. In light of the lack of interest I see around us, I think the voting percentage will be low, at least in Israeli terms.

By the way, it appears that Sarah Palin is a hit here with the average working class males. In other words, picture election rallies packed with Al Bundys and you'll begin to understand how this can happen. I guess that the fact that the talented and attractive Tina Fey plays her role in Saturday Night Live doesn't hurt, although the writers in SNL are pro-Democrats. Last week Sarah Palin even appeared as a guest in SNL, thus leveraging both the show's rating and Fey's popularity. You should catch a glimpse of this appearance if you haven't already done so.

Something less known is that in the same day people are voting for various offices other than the president. There are of course the U.S. Congress and Senate, but there are also more local offices. Here they vote for judges, district attorneys, state representatives, and even "clerk of courts". I don't really know what that is, but it appears to be someone who is responsible for signing official documents, like a document that title your vehicle in your name. We went to the bureau of motor vehicles (BMV) and titled our Altima in both our names. We also purchased our license plates (here they identify the person or group owning the vehicle, not the vehicle itself). The BMV seemed a more organized and has less bureaucracy than the university. Somehow, my impressions of the federal and state authorities are that they are far more efficient than the university. That's not too hard, I guess.

I read in Ynet that Israel is heading back to elections. Here are some good reasons to elect Benyamin Netanyahu as prime minister:
  1. He did a good job as a treasurer and since we face a big economic crisis he can set a good example on how to lead Israel to economic haven.
  2. He is against government expenditures. He'll probably be able to deal with Shas and prevent them from getting a billion sheqels out of our pockets.
  3. The other options are Ehud Barak and Zipi Livni. It's not that there is someone far better than Bibi to elect.
  4. Governments usually fall within two, maximum two and a half years, in Israel. If Bibi is elected this year, he will be gone by 2011, just in time to correct his mistakes before D and I are back. :-)
To summarize, a story that combine bureaucracy and politics. Yesterday was D's half a day off from her studies, after she returned from a midterm exam (yes, I know, it was Saturday, but hey that's Business School for you). Unfortunately, soon after she got home, the toilet overflowed, and we were afraid that the entire day would be ruined. We called the lousy company that rents our building, and they asked us to try and resolve the situation by ourselves. We thought about calling Joe the Plumber, who is - as you all know - an Ohioan, but finally we decided to buy a plunger and do it ourselves. It worked out, so now I am considering to become a plumber myself. After all, it is a good occupation even in times of economic dire; people will still need someone to plunge their toilets or install a new faucet. I will be better paid than what I make now, that's for sure. Even Joe the plumber makes more than me.